We all have opinions and experiences that we want to share with others, especially when they are facing a problem or a dilemma. We may think that we are being helpful and supportive by offering our advice, but sometimes we may be doing more harm than good. Here are some reasons why you should think twice before you give others advice.
You may not have the full picture
When someone tells you about their situation, they may not give you all the details or context that are relevant to their decision. They may simplify or exaggerate some aspects of their story, or they may not be aware of some factors that influence their choices. As a result, you may not have a clear understanding of their problem and its causes, and your advice may be based on incomplete or inaccurate information.
For example, if your friend tells you that they are unhappy with their job and want to quit, you may be tempted to tell them to go for it and pursue their passion. But you may not know that they have a family to support, a mortgage to pay, or a health condition that requires insurance coverage. Your advice may sound encouraging and inspiring, but it may also be unrealistic and irresponsible.
You may have your own biases
We all have our own perspectives and preferences that shape how we see the world and how we make decisions. These biases can affect how we evaluate information, how we interpret situations, and how we judge others. Sometimes we are not even aware of our own biases, or we may think that they are universal truths.
When we give advice to others, we may unconsciously project our own biases onto them and assume that they share our values and goals. We may also ignore or dismiss evidence that contradicts our views or opinions. This can lead us to give advice that is more suitable for ourselves than for the person we are trying to help.
For instance, if you are an introvert who values privacy and solitude, you may advise your extroverted friend who is feeling lonely to spend more time alone and enjoy their own company. But this advice may not work for them, because they have different needs and preferences than you. They may feel more fulfilled and energized by socializing with others and seeking new experiences.
You may interfere with their autonomy
One of the most important aspects of human dignity is the ability to make our own choices and take responsibility for our own actions. When we face a problem or a dilemma, we want to feel that we have some control over our situation and that we can find a solution that works for us. We also want to learn from our mistakes and grow as individuals.
When we give advice to others, we may unintentionally undermine their autonomy and agency. We may make them feel that they are not capable of solving their own problems or that they need our approval or validation. We may also discourage them from exploring other options or perspectives that may be more suitable for them. We may even create a sense of obligation or indebtedness in them that can affect our relationship.
For example, if your colleague asks you for your opinion on a project they are working on, you may give them some constructive feedback and suggestions on how to improve it. But if you go too far and tell them exactly what to do and how to do it, you may make them feel that they have no say in their own work or that they have to follow your instructions to please you. You may also prevent them from discovering new ideas or approaches that could enhance their creativity and performance.
How to give better advice
This does not mean that you should never give advice to anyone. Advice can be a valuable form of support and guidance when it is given with care and respect. Here are some tips on how to give better advice:
- Ask before you advise: Before you offer your unsolicited advice, ask the person if they want your input or if they just want someone to listen. Respect their wishes and don’t impose your opinions on them.
- Listen before you advise: Before you jump to conclusions or solutions, listen carefully and attentively to what the person is telling you. Try to understand their situation, their feelings, their goals, and their challenges. Ask open-ended questions to clarify any doubts or gaps in your understanding.
- Empathize before you advise: Before you judge or criticize the person’s choices or actions, try to empathize with their emotions and motivations. Put yourself in their shoes and imagine how they feel and what they want. Acknowledge their feelings and validate their concerns.
- Advise with humility: Before you give your advice, acknowledge that you may not have all the answers or that your advice may not be the best or the only option. Remind the person that they have the final say in their decision and that they know their situation better than you. Offer your advice as a suggestion or a possibility, not as a command or a fact.
- Advise with respect: Before you give your advice, consider how it may affect the person’s self-esteem, confidence, and autonomy. Avoid being harsh, rude, or condescending. Use positive and supportive language. Respect their right to disagree or reject your advice.
Wellbeing Arena 